It's a pro-democracy movement. And it's global.
The vibrant social forces that converged on Seattle -- and proceeded to
deflate the WTO summit -- are complex, diverse and sometimes contradictory.
Yet the threads of their demands form a distinct weave: We want full
democratic rights for all people.
Leaders of the U.S. government are pleased to say nice things about some
pro-democracy movements -- far away. But here at home, their pretense is
that the conditions of democracy have already been achieved.
Yes, many of us sampled those conditions in Seattle, complete with tear
gas and pepper spray, thick batons and rubber bullets. The law-enforcement
partners of the WTO pursued the goal of routing protesters in much the same
way that top officials of the WTO go about reaching trade agreements. They
want to do whatever it takes -- to maintain control and preserve the power
of elites.
The marketeers who are so fervent about the glories of the WTO are
determined to preserve the kind of social order described a century ago by
writer Anatole France: "The law, in its majestic equality, forbids the rich
as well as the poor to sleep under bridges, to beg in the streets, and to
steal bread."
As U.S. Congress member Dennis Kucinich commented the other day, the World
Trade Organization has achieved great transparency -- we can see right
through it.
Genuine pro-democracy movements are always profoundly threatening to those
with their polished boots on the necks of the poor. In the United States,
corporate-owned media -- and corporate-leased politicians -- don't see any
fundamental problem. The system is treating them very well, thank you, and
they're returning the favor. (Or is it the other way around?)
America's punditocracy is adept at changing the subject, away from the
basics. But the obvious -- like the purloined letter in Edgar Allen Poe's
classic tale -- is often so omni-present that it goes unnoticed. Every
daily newspaper in the U.S. has a business section; none has a labor
section. On NPR, even though "Public" is its middle name, there's not even
a weekly labor update -- while the same network airs an hourly NPR
"business update."
The implicit media assumption that wealth creates all labor is simply
another inversion of reality. What passes for mainstream journalism is
standing on its head in order to serve corporate interests, as we've seen
yet again. Carried in a march through Seattle, a huge banner noted: "The
Corporate Media Diverts Your Attention from Police and WTO Violence."
"The Capital Gang" is just one of many network TV programs providing an
incessant national chorus of corporate-friendly political pundits. It's an
apt metaphor: Although we're supposed to assume that the name of the CNN
show is a reference to Washington, D.C., my guess is that "Capital" could
be more appropriately understood as financial capital.
If a pro-democracy movement is going to grow much more in this country, it
must deal with the reality that the news media are hostile to populism that
is progressive -- but appreciably more hospitable to the right-wing variety.
The first political pundit to appear on national TV seven days a week was
Patrick Buchanan. Now he wants the Reform Party's presidential nomination.
Buchanan has become fond of voicing anti-corporate sentiments. He came to
Seattle trolling for votes from the anti-WTO bandwagon. Meanwhile, he
doesn't support basic union rights of American workers. Significantly, he
opposes a raise in the minimum wage. And he scorns the environmental
movement as an affront to holiness. "Easter's gone," Buchanan declared
angrily a few years ago. "Now it's Earth Day. We can all go out and worship
dirt."
From Corporate America's vantage point, Pat Buchanan is just about ideal
as a national candidate waving the populist banner. Buchanan is hobbled by
heavy far-right baggage -- which he grips with white-knuckled defiance as
he equivocates about Nazi Germany and routinely denigrates people for
failure to be white, heterosexual and Christian (as he defines Christian).
In sharp contrast, the progressive forces at work in Seattle have boosted
momentum for democratic change. We're learning to reach out across borders
and many other barriers, finding out how to affirm our common humanity
while struggling against corporate power. As hundreds of people kept
chanting outside the King County Correctional Facility during a festive
celebration of resistance on the night of December 2: "This is what
democracy looks like."
A global pro-democracy movement. The time has come.
Norman Solomon's latest book The Habits of Highly Deceptive Media: Decoding Spin and Lies in Mainstream News has
just won the 1999 George Orwell Award for Distinguished Contribution to
Honesty and Clarity in Public Language, presented by the National Council
of Teachers of English.